Free Agent Fantasy Preview
Would you believe that not a single restricted free agent changed teams last year out of the 54 that were eligible? In the previous four years, only four percent of the 345 available restricted free agents changed teams. Contrast that with the 1,621 unrestricted free agents over the same time period, forty percent of whom moved on to greener pastures.
Teams are understandably loath to part with draft picks, the lifeblood of NFL rosters. By the time free agency rolls around, scouts and coaches are more excited about the prospects they just ogled at the NFL Combine. Why part with a pick to sign a restricted free agent when you can land a more talented player in the draft while holding his rights for four years?
It's for that reason that this article will emphasize unrestricted free agents and candidates to be traded or released while glossing over the restricted free agent batch. Our goal is to analyze the fantasy implications of this year's free agent crop, so we are most interested in those players changing teams.
Before moving on to the lists, it should be pointed out that the free agency rules have been somewhat modified this year due to the lack of a new collective bargaining agreement. Traditionally, players reach unrestricted free agency after their third or fourth year in the league. This year, however, all players must reach six years before controlling their own destiny. The result is a glut of restricted free agents -- approximately 200 – that would have been free under the old system. As you will see, there are more big names (especially at wide receiver) than ever falling into the category this year.
[SIZE=+1]Quarterbacks[/SIZE]
Restricted Free Agents: Jason Campbell, Kyle Orton, Matt Moore, Bruce Gradkowski, Tarvaris Jackson, Troy Smith, Kellen Clemens, Brodie Croyle, Charlie Frye, John Beck
Campbell and Orton aren't going anywhere on first-round tenders. Orton is a mortal lock to open Week 1 as the Broncos starter, and Campbell isn't far behind as the Redskins' likely starter. Orton stands to lose fantasy value with a potential Brandon Marshall exit while Campbell needs an impact No. 1 receiver to garner serious consideration as a high-end QB2 -- even with the upgrade to Mike Shanahan's offense.
Moore and Gradkowski will be extended at least second-round tenders. Considering their "competition" consists of Jake Delhomme and JaMarcus Russell – quite possibly the two worst starters in the league last season – both should be considered prohibitive favorites. Moore's relative success (6-2 record with 11 touchdowns and three interceptions in eight career starts) gives him a leg up on Gradkowski (career 53.3 completion percentage and 5.4 yards per attempt) as a potential deep sleeper.
Unrestricted Free Agents:
Chad Pennington: We anointed Pennington the best of the dark-horse quarterbacks in deep leagues two weeks ago. With Pat White and Tyler Thigpen behind Chad Henne, a Miami return is unlikely. Coming off a third shoulder surgery, Pennington needs to prove he can at least make the throws he was making in 2008. If so, he would make for an ideal sparring partner for Matt Leinart in training camp. Outside of Arizona, it's tough to envision Pennington with fantasy value.
Prediction: Cardinals
Fantasy Afterthoughts: David Carr, Chris Redman, Jeff Garcia, Rex Grossman, Daunte Culpepper, J.P. Losman, Kyle Boller
Let's be honest: this QB free agent class is a joke. None of the passers on the above list have a shot to get drafted in fantasy leagues this summer, and most will not even appear in a game in 2010.
Trade Candidates:
Donovan McNabb / Kevin Kolb: If the Eagles weren't in a playoff window, this would be a much easier decision. As it is, though, McNabb offers Andy Reid the best chance to win now while Kolb remains the quarterback of the future. Unless they receive the proverbial "offer they can't refuse," the Eagles appear poised to let McNabb finish out his contract at age 33 while working toward an extension with Kolb. At this point, both quarterbacks seem likely to stay in Philly.
Prediction: Both stay with Eagles
Michael Vick: The Eagles are doing their best sell-job, trying to convince the rest of the league that Vick will stay put if they don't receive a high draft pick as compensation. So far the only person taking the bait is NFL Network's Michael Lombardi. Unless the Eagles have a plan in place to deal either McNabb or Kolb, it makes no sense to fork out over $5 million for Vick in 2010. The smart money still has him landing elsewhere. The Rams will have a hard time passing up Sam Bradford, which would leave the Bills as the team in most need of Vick's services. Having gone four years without starting a game, he'd be nothing more than a high-upside QB2 as a starter.
Prediction: Bills
Troy Smith: Though Smith and his agent have been pushing for a trade, the Ravens don't seem obliged to comply.
Prediction: Ravens
Tyler Thigpen: Intriguing athletic ability but only an option in a gimmick offense. Even if Chan Gailey wants to reunite with Thigpen, he's not going to run the spread offense in Buffalo's elements. Expect Thigpen to stay in Miami.
Prediction: Dolphins' No. 2 QB
Candidates for Release: Derek Anderson, Marc Bulger, Byron Leftwich, Kerry Collins, Chris Simms
Similar to Pennington, Bulger's only chance for fantasy value is to land in a high-scoring offense with top-flight receivers already in place. He can't handle blitzes at this stage of his career, so consistency will be a factor. Anderson was positively brutal last season, as befitting a passer with a career 52.9 completion percentage. Leftwich's starting days are over after he flunked out as the Bucs starter in less than a month. Collins and Simms won't land in situations any better than those they occupied at the end of the season.
Teams in the Market: Rams, Bills, Browns, Raiders, Redskins, Cardinals, Panthers, Seahawks, Broncos, Jaguars
<!--RW-->
[SIZE=+1]Running Backs[/SIZE]
Restricted Free Agents: Ronnie Brown, Pierre Thomas, Jerome Harrison, Carnell Williams, LenDale White, Leon Washington, Jason Snelling, Jerious Norwood, Le'Ron McClain, Mike Bell, Ryan Moats
Thomas is the one player from this list who could (and should) draw an offer sheet. One of the most effective per-play backs in the league the past two seasons, Thomas was tendered at just a second-round level by the Saints. A team like the Chargers would be wise to swoop in for the steal, but they'll be hesitant to hand out a hefty contract in the process. Despite Sean Payton's obsession with limiting Thomas' workload, New Orleans' high-flying offense remains his best bet for fantasy value.
Unrestricted Free Agents:
Darren Sproles: Technically still a RFA, Sproles is free to sign with any team after the Chargers declined to tender him an offer. Redskins owner Daniel Snyder is expected to throw around money "like it's Monopoly" while coach Mike Shanahan "covets" the pint-sized playmaker. Chargers GM A.J. Smith has made it clear that he's sees Sproles as nothing more than a change-of-pace back with return ability, so it's not a stretch to imagine the most explosive free agent back finding a bigger payday with a team such as the Redskins. Though he's likely to remain on returns regardless, Sproles has a chance to increase his offensive touches with the LaDainian Tomlinson quota out of the picture. Considering his past per-touch production, RB2 value is a realistic projection – especially in PPR leagues.
Prediction: Redskins
Thomas Jones: The Rodney Dangerfield of the NFL, Jones gets no respect. Just like the Bears and Jets, we're guilty as charged. The history of aging running backs simply leaves a 32-year-old with five consecutive seasons of 290+ carries a poor bet for continued success. In a just world, Jones' back-to-back career years at ages 30 and 31 would afford him the benefit of the doubt. In the NFL, however, the sharp late-season decline that saw him severely outplayed by Shonn Greene will leave him as a complementary back in his new home. Potential suitors include the Chargers, Lions, Eagles, and Browns. In fantasy terms, San Diego would be his ideal landing spot as a possible RB2.
Prediction: Chargers
Chester Taylor: A free-agent success with the Vikings four years ago, Taylor broke off 1,502 yards and a top-12 fantasy finish before Adrian Peterson's arrival on the scene. Now 30 and coming off three seasons as possibly the best third-down back in the game, Taylor is hoping free-agent lightning strikes twice. Though he makes sense for plenty of teams (Vikings, Bears, Eagles, Browns), his best fantasy bet may be Detroit, where he could hold down the fort for Kevin Smith.
Prediction: Lions
Brian Westbrook: As opposed to dead men walking such as Clinton Portis, Jamal Lewis, and even LaDainian Tomlinson, Westbrook's 4.5 yards per carry in 2009 suggests he still has life left in his legs. Given a dozen touches per game, he could sniff RB2 numbers. For NFL and fantasy purposes alike, though, there isn't a bigger health risk in the game. In addition to the well-publicized concussion concerns, teams are just as leery of his troublesome left knee and right ankle. Although a reunion with Brad Childress in Minnesota is the most logical fit, recent word has Westbrook unlikely to choose a team that plays on turf. The Bears, Steelers, and Niners are grass-field teams that could use a player with Westbrook's skill-set.
Prediction: Vikings
LaDainian Tomlinson: We covered Tomlinson's free agent outlook last week. In a word, it's bleak. Tomlinson is far from an ideal third-down back at this stage of his career, and his 3.3 yards per carry and lifeless legs suggest his feature-back days are over. If he truly wants to play for a contender, LT is going to have to accept a short-yardage complementary role on a team such as the Eagles or Saints. No matter where he ends up, the future Hall of Famer is a player to shy away from in fantasy circles.
Prediction: Eagles
Willie Parker: Hitting the market at age 29, the artist formerly known as "Fast Willie" has lost his fastball. Though Parker did exhibit fresh legs in the season finale, he spent most of the season watching holes close before he could get to them. Always a poor bet to play 16 games, Parker will have to accept a the lesser half of a timeshare role with his new team.
Prediction: Browns
Larry Johnson: Now 30 years old, L.J. is a locker-room cancer and publicity nightmare coming off a 3.2 yards-per-carry season. Any team looking to sign him would do themselves a favor by comparing his production to Jamaal Charles' with the Chiefs last season. Johnson ran for just 2.7 yards per carry behind the same line that saw Charles explode for 5.9. L.J. is a longshot for a fantasy impact in 2010.
Fantasy Afterthoughts: Jamal Lewis, Kevin Faulk, Ahman Green, Chris Brown, Adrian Peterson
Candidates for Trade / Release:
Marshawn Lynch: With Fred Jackson having finally established himself as the superior back, a Lynch trade makes sense if the Bills can extract a couple of decent draft picks. They have enough holes on the roster that the extra draft picks will come in handy. If the offers don't roll in, however, Lynch will return as the Robin to F-Jax's Batman in Chan Gailey's two-back system. For the sake of both backs' fantasy value, a trade is the ideal scenario.
Tashard Choice: This appears to be the case of one whisper starting a chain reaction. Ever since the bogus Antonio Cromartie rumor, Choice's name has popped up on lists of backs available for trade, despite all indications from Dallas to the contrary. Choice will return to the Big D -- possibly with a slightly bigger role in 2009 – but he won't have value in most leagues until the first injury to Felix Jones or Marion Barber.
Justin Fargas / Michael Bush: Scout.com has pointed out that Fargas is due a roster bonus this spring, but the Tom Cable favorite is expected to remain in silver and black. The 30-year-old banger will continue to split carries in the Oakland backfield, leaving him undraftable in most fantasy leagues.
Bush, the Raiders' most effective per-play back the past two seasons, has seemingly been on the block since he entered the league. Unlike Fargas, he hasn't been able to earn the trust of the current coaching staff. Bush would make sense as a power back in Norv Turner's offense, but Al Davis won't trade him within the division. With all of the high-profile names now available on the free agent market, he's not a good bet to land the greater share of a committee attack.
Ladell Betts: Due $1.65 million, Betts is a candidate for release coming off a torn MCL and ACL. With both ligaments torn, he's a poor bet to return to pre-injury form at age 31.
Teams in the Market for a Running Back: Chargers, Texans, Seahawks, Lions, Browns, Redskins, Eagles, Rams, Jets, Bears, Patriots, Vikings, Chiefs, 49ers, Steelers, Giants
<!--RW-->
[SIZE=+1]Wide Receivers[/SIZE]
Restricted Free Agents: Vincent Jackson, Miles Austin, Brandon Marshall, Braylon Edwards, Steve Breaston, Malcom Floyd, Mark Clayton, Domenik Hixon, Jason Avant, Lance Moore, Demetrius Williams, Brad Smith, Maurice Stovall, Troy Williamson, Sinorice Moss
Vincent Jackson and Miles Austin were dominant talents in 2009, among the top five players at their position. Considering the burn-out rate of draft picks, one could certainly make the argument that both playmaking receivers are worth the cost of a first- and third-round draft pick.
Fortunately for the Chargers and Cowboys, pilfering a restricted free agent involves much more complexity. Most teams signing a high-profile restricted free agent also attempt to lock up the player long-term, which means not only parting with draft picks but also paying through the nose in terms of salary. In effect, teams are paying double.
Even if this double jeopardy fails to scare off a potential suitor, the team holding the players' rights still has the opportunity to match all offers. For all of these reasons, no restricted free agents given the first-and-third tender have changed teams over the past five seasons. The one traditional loophole a/k/a the "poison pill" isn't considered a serious threat because the NFL has cracked down on the highly questionable tactic.
While Brandon Marshall still seems likely to leave Denver, Vincent and Austin will stay in San Diego and Dallas respectively.
Unrestricted Free Agents
Antonio Bryant: As an NFL free agent, Bryant is riddled with question marks. One of the biggest knuckleheads in the league over the past decade, the 29-year-old carries a ton of baggage. He'll also have to answer questions about a knee injury that nagged him off-and-on throughout the entirety of the 2009 season. Finally, he's long been known as an unwilling blocker and an indifferent route runner. On the flip side, he's quite possibly the most talented pass-catcher on the open market. If healthy, Bryant is still young enough to produce WR2 value with a quarterback upgrade this year.
Prediction: Redskins
Terrell Owens: This much we know: T.O. has struggled to beat press coverage for the past two seasons, and his production was artificially deflated by the crumbling Bills' offensive line and quarterback play last season. If he wasn't 36-years-old, Owens would be primed for a monstrous comeback season. As it is, his numbers are still likely to rebound somewhat – as long as he lands in a functional offense this time around.
Prediction: Lions
Nate Burleson: One of the few receivers available with the talent to play inside and outside, Burleson's free agent value will be depressed by his injury history. Though he was solid last season as the Seahawks' co-number one with T.J. Houshmandzadeh, Burleson's ideal role is second fiddle to a more dynamic receiver. He's ticketed for borderline WR3 fantasy value in almost any destination.
Prediction: Seahawks
Chris Chambers: Left for dead by the Chargers early last season, Chambers resurrected his career with his Chiefs during Dwayne Bowe's suspension in December. Though he can still make the difficult grab, the 32-year-old has not produced consistently since 2005. Chambers won't be a hot commodity on the open market, so the best fit may be a return to Kansas City as Bowe's sidekick – and no better than a WR4/5 for fantasy purposes.
Predicition: Chiefs
Derrick Mason: The 36-year-old is a free agent in name only, since he's going to re-sign with the Ravens. Mason wants a multi-year deal and indications are the Ravens are willing to go to two years, so he's not going anywhere. Baltimore ideally wants to add a No. 1 receiver to push Mason into a subsidiary role, which means his fantasy stock could plummet in 2010.
Prediction: Ravens
Kevin Walter: A better NFL than fantasy player, Walter is a role player stretched as a No. 2 receiver. If he couldn't produce WR3 numbers in the Texans' high-powered offense, he's going to have a hard time getting back on the fantasy radar again in 2010. Let someone else use their late-round pick on him this summer.
Prediction: Bills
Torry Holt: The Panthers have been trying to find a young complement to Steve Smith for years, but they value solid citizens over any sign of a character risk. Holt has a bit more gas left in the tank than Muhsin Muhammad, and Carolina offers him a chance to return home. Regardless of his new home, Holt's days as even a WR3 are over.
Prediction: Panthers
No Fantasy Value: Muhsin Muhammad, Josh Reed, Joey Galloway, Kelley Washington, Bobby Wade, Arnaz Battle, Mark Bradley
Candidates for Trade:
Anquan Boldin: Before this year, it never made sense for the Cardinals to deal Boldin for the underwhelming offers they were received. A team leader and fierce competitor, Boldin was an asset with a cheap contract playing for a contender. Now that he enters the final year of his deal with Early Doucet and Steve Breaston ready to take on more responsibility in the passing game, the Cardinals would be best served by accepting the highest offer they receive for Boldin. The Ravens, a contender in their own right, have an obvious need for a big, physical go-to receiver who can make plays in the red zone. Boldin is an obvious fit, and the Ravens should be able to land him with a third-rounder this year plus an added 2011 pick.
Prediction: Ravens
Brandon Marshall: The Broncos' tender offer is essentially a dare to any team willing to part with a first-round pick to sign the biggest character risk in the league. Josh McDaniels & Co. realized no team was going to surrender more than a first-round pick in trade, with Marshall also demanding a new mega-deal. I'm not buying a quality organization such as the Ravens making a play for Marshall. It's going to take a franchise with a vacancy at playmaker and a willingness to throw caution to the wind. If the Bengals sense an opportunity for a bargain deal, they'll dive in head-first on a talented character risk such as Marshall. No matter where he ends up, Marshall carries borderline WR1 fantasy value as long as he can stay on the field.
Prediction: Bengals
Teams in the Market for a Wide Receiver: Ravens, Dolphins, Buccaneers, Panthers, Bengals, Lions, Redskins, Bills, Chiefs, Seahawks, Jaguars, Patriots
<!--RW-->
[SIZE=+1]Tight Ends[/SIZE]
Restricted Free Agents: Owen Daniels, Tony Scheffler, Bo Scaife, Anthony Fasano, David Thomas, Jeff King
Though Daniels (ACL surgery) is threatening to hold out of training camp, his hands are tied. He'll be back in Houston. Expected to be tendered by the Titans despite his high price tag, Scaife will have to hold off the raw but talented Jared Cook. Fasano will be back in Miami, but his value is negligible. Thomas' best fantasy bet remains New Orleans, though he needs a Jeremy Shockey injury for weekly consideration.
Unrestricted Free Agents:
Ben Watson: Once a promising pass-catcher, Watson tallied a career-high 645 yards and a tenth-place fantasy finish in 2006 before the Pats grew wary of his come-and-go hands. Now 29 and possessing solid blocking skills to go with above-average athletic ability, Watson stands to benefit from a change of scenery. In the right offense, he could conceivably regain high-end TE2 value.
Prediction: Chiefs
Injury-Prone Veterans: Randy McMichael, L.J. Smith, David Martin, Billy Miller
All four of the above can catch the ball, but they offer nothing in the way of blocking ability or durability. Though any of the four could pop up on fantasy waiver wires in 2010, there's just as much of a chance that they'll be out of the league. Despite missing the 2009 season with a torn Achille's tendon, Profootballfocus.com named Miller their "diamond in the rough" in this year's free agent class. I wouldn't hold my breath.
Fantasy Afterthoughts: Brandon Manumaleuna, Alge Crumpler, Alex Smith, Ben Hartsock, Leonard Pope
Trade Candidates:
Tony Scheffler: Though he was extended a low tender offer, no team is going to part with a second-round pick to sign Scheffler. The Broncos literally have no use for him, so he should be available on the cheap – possibly for a fourth-round pick and change. With their West Coast offense, the Rams make for a nice fit. As we've seen with Vernon Davis, a system change can make the difference between a fantasy afterthought and a weekly asset. Scheffler has the talent to post borderline TE1 numbers in a new offense next season.
Prediction: Rams
Greg Olsen: Trade rumors, quite possibly started by Olsen and his agent, have been flying around since the weekend. Olsen understands that his role will shrink under Mike Martz, and the Bears could also learn a lesson from the Broncos about the diminishing trade value of an under-utilized tight end. If the Pats were willing to part with one of their three second-round picks, Olsen will give them opportunity to put the tight end back into their own offense (Again, see Ben Watson's 2006 season).
Prediction: Patriots
Teams in the Market for a Tight End: St. Louis, Buffalo, Cincinnati, New England, Kansas City, Carolina, Cleveland, Arizona, Denver